Blog Details

A/B testing is the fastest way to stop guessing and start knowing what actually works on your website.

Simple as that.

What Is A/B Testing?

A/B testing means showing two versions of the same page to different people.

• Then you see which one performs better.
• Version A gets shown to half your visitors.
• Version B gets shown to the other half.

Whichever gets more clicks, sales, or sign-ups wins.

• You keep the winner forever.

Here’s the thing most people miss.

• You’re already losing money right now.
• Your website could be better. But you don’t know how.

A/B testing tells you exactly what to fix.

• No guessing. No opinions. Just facts.

Why A/B Testing Matters More Than You Think?

Let me show you with real numbers.

• You have a website that gets 10,000 visitors per month.
• Your conversion rate is 2%.
• That’s 200 customers.
• You run an A/B testing project.
• You test a new headline.
• The new version converts at 2.5%.
• That’s 250 customers instead of 200.
• 50 extra customers every single month.
• If each customer is worth £100, that’s £5,000 extra per month.
• £60,000 extra per year.

From one headline change.

That’s why smart companies spend money on A/B testing.

How Does A/B Testing Actually Work?

Most people think this is complicated.

It’s not.

Here are the 5 steps:

Step 1: Pick what you want to test

• Maybe it’s your headline.
• Maybe it’s your button colour.
• Maybe it’s your product photo.
• Pick one thing. Just one.

Step 2: Create version B

• Keep your original (version A).
• Make one change for version B.
• Change the headline. Or the button. Or the image.
• Don’t change everything at once.

Step 3: Split your traffic

Half your visitors see version A.

Half see version B.

Your testing tool does this automatically.

Step 4: Wait for results

• You need at least 1,000 visitors per version.
• Usually takes 2-4 weeks.
• Don’t stop the test early.

Step 5: Pick the winner

Did version B get more sales?

• Keep it.
• Did version A perform better?
• Keep the original.

Then test something else.

This is what every A/B testing expert does every single day.

Best Tools for A/B Testing

You need the right tools to run proper tests.

Here are the best ones:

Google Optimize (Free)

Perfect for beginners.

Works with Google Analytics.

Easy to set up.

Completely free.

VWO A/B Testing

Professional grade tool.

Used by big companies.

Great for SEO A/B testing.

Has heat maps and recordings.

Starts at £199 per month.

Optimizely

Enterprise level platform.

Best for companies with lots of traffic.

Expensive but powerful.

Custom pricing (usually £2,000+ per month).

Microsoft Clarity (Free)

Not technically an A/B testing tool.

But shows you what to test.

Heat maps show where people click.

Session recordings show where people get stuck.

Completely free forever.

Most A/B testing services use a combination of these tools.

SEO A/B Testing (Don’t Mess This Up)

Here’s something most people don’t know.

SEO A/B testing can help or destroy your rankings.

Let me explain.

What Is SEO A/B Testing?

SEO A/B testing means testing changes that affect Google rankings.

Things like:

• Title tags
• Meta descriptions
• Page structure
• Internal linking
• Content length

You can’t just test these things like normal.

Google needs to see consistent content.

How to Do SEO A/B Testing Safely?

Split your pages into two groups.

• Group A stays the same.
• Group B gets the change.

Watch both groups for 4-8 weeks.

Did Group B’s traffic increase?

Roll out the change to all pages.

Did nothing happen?

Keep things as they are.

This is advanced stuff.

Most companies hire experts for SEO A/B testing.

Because one mistake can tank your rankings.

Local SEO A/B Testing for Small Businesses

Running a local business? This matters.

Local SEO A/B testing helps you show up in local searches.

Here’s what to test:

Test Your Google Business Profile

• Try different business descriptions.
• Test different photos.

Try different service categories.

See which gets more calls and visits.

Test Your Local Landing Pages

Create two versions of your location page.

• Test different headlines:
• Version A: “Best Plumber in Manchester”
• Version B: “Emergency Plumber Manchester – 24/7 Service”

See which gets more calls.

Test Your NAP (Name, Address, Phone)

This sounds silly but matters.

• Test showing your phone number at the top vs. bottom.
• Test click-to-call buttons vs. plain numbers.
• Small changes = big results for local SEO A/B testing.

A/B Testing Social Media That Actually Works

A/B testing social media is different from website testing.

Here’s how to do it right:

Test Your Ad Creative

• Run two versions of the same ad.
• Keep the audience the same.

Change one element:

• The image
• The headline
• The first sentence
• The call-to-action

Facebook and Instagram do this automatically now.

Just turn on “dynamic creative” in the ads manager.

Test Your Posting Times

• Post the same content at different times.
• Monday at 9am vs. Tuesday at 2pm.
• Track which gets more engagement.

Do more of what works.

Test Your Content Format

• Same message, different format.
• Test carousel vs. single image.
• Test video vs. photo.
• Test stories vs. feed posts.

A/B testing social media is about finding what your audience actually likes.

Not what you think they like.

A/B Testing for Video Content (The New Gold Mine)

A/B testing for video content is huge right now.

YouTube and TikTok let you test everything.

Here’s what works:

Test Your Thumbnails

• Upload your video.
• Create 3 different thumbnails.
• YouTube shows each one to different people.

After a week, YouTube keeps the best performer.

This one change can double your views.

Test Your First 3 Seconds

Most people leave in the first 3 seconds.

Test different openings:

• Version A: “In this video…”
• Version B: “Here’s how to make £1,000…”

The second one keeps people watching longer.

Test Your Video Length

Same content, different lengths.

• Try a 3-minute version and a 7-minute version.
• See which gets better watch time.

Good A/B testing for video content focuses on watch time, not just views.

Advanced A/B Testing: Bayesian A/B Testing

Bayesian A/B testing sounds fancy.

It’s just smarter testing.

Here’s the difference:

Traditional A/B Testing

• You pick a sample size upfront.
• You wait until you hit that number.
• Then you stop and pick a winner.

Bayesian A/B Testing

• You can check the results any time.
• You can stop early if one version is clearly winning.
• You get a probability score: “Version B has a 95% chance of being better.”
• It’s faster and more flexible.
• Most modern tools use Bayesian A/B testing

You don’t need to understand the maths.

The tool does it for you.

A/B Testing Mistakes That Kill Results

Here’s where people mess up:

Mistake 1: Testing Too Many Things at Once

You change your headline, image, button, and colours all at once.

• Version B performs better.
• Great! But you don’t know which change worked.
• Test one thing at a time. Always.

Mistake 2: Stopping Tests Too Early

You see version B is winning after 2 days.

• You declare victory and stop the test.
• But you only had 100 visitors.
• That’s not enough data.

Run tests for at least 2 weeks with 1,000+ visitors per version.

Mistake 3: Testing Random Stuff

You test button colours because someone said “red converts better.”

But your real problem is that your headline is confusing.

Test big things first:

• Headlines
• Value propositions
• Call-to-action text
• Page structure

Then test small things like colours.

Mistake 4: Ignoring Mobile

• 70% of your traffic is on mobile.
• Your test looks great on the desktop.
• But it’s broken on phones.

Always test on mobile first.

When to Hire A/B Testing Services

Sometimes you need professional help.

Here’s when:

You’re Spending Over £5,000 Per Month on Ads

• If you’re paying for traffic, you need to convert it better.
• A 1% improvement = thousands of pounds extra profit.

Professional A/B testing services pay for themselves fast.

You Don’t Have Time to Learn

A/B testing takes time to master.

If you’re busy running your business, hire a company who have experts like Shieldonsystems.

They already know what works.

Your Tests Keep Failing

• You’ve run 10 tests.
• Nothing improved.

You’re doing something wrong.

Hire experts who can spot the problems you can’t see.

You Need Platform-Specific Help

• Klaviyo A/B testing for email marketing.
• Webflow A/B testing for custom websites.

Platform specialists know the tricks and shortcuts.

How Much Does A/B Testing Cost?

Let’s talk about real numbers.

DIY A/B Testing

• Cost: Free to £199/month for tools
• Your time: 5-10 hours per week
• Good for: Small businesses just starting

Freelance A/B Testing Consultant

• Cost: £75-£200 per hour
• Usually 10-20 hours per month
• Good for: Mid-sized businesses

A/B Testing Agency

• Cost: £2,000-£10,000 per month
• Full service: strategy, testing, analysis
• Good for: Companies spending £10,000+ on ads

A/B Testing Project

• Cost: £3,000-£15,000 one-time
• Includes: audit, strategy, 3-5 tests
• Good for: One-off optimization

The return on investment is usually 3-10x what you spend.

Because you’re making more from the traffic you already have.

Real Results from A/B Testing Projects

Let me share a real example.

• We worked with an online education company.
• They sold courses for £500 each.
• Getting 5,000 visitors per month.
• Converting at 1.5% = 75 sales = £37,500 per month.

Here’s what we tested in our A/B testing project:

Test 1: Changed the headline

• From “Learn Digital Marketing”
• To “Get a £50k Marketing Job in 6 Months”
• Result: Conversion increased to 1.8%

Test 2: Added social proof

• Added “Join 10,000+ students” badge at the top.
• Result: Conversion increased to 2.1%

Test 3: Simplified the sign-up form

• Removed 3 unnecessary fields.
• Result: Conversion increased to 2.5%
• Final result: 2.5% conversion rate.

Same 5,000 visitors.

• Now 125 sales per month instead of 75.
• That’s 50 extra sales × £500 = £25,000 extra per month.
• £300,000 extra per year.

From three simple tests.

That’s the power of proper A/B testing.

How to Get Started with A/B Testing Today?

You don’t need a big budget.

Start right now:

Step 1: Set up Google Optimize (Free)

• It takes 20 minutes.
• Connect it to Google Analytics.

You’re ready to test.

Step 2: Pick your worst-performing page

• Look at your analytics.
• Which page has the highest bounce rate?
• Start there.

Step 3: Make one simple change

• Don’t overthink it.
• Change your headline to be clearer.
• Or make your button bigger and brighter.

One change only.

Step 4: Run the test for 2 weeks

• Don’t check it every day.
• Let it run for at least 1,000 visitors.

Step 5: Keep the winner and test again

• Did version B win? Keep it.
• Did version A win? Keep the original.
• Then test something else.
• Repeat forever.

The best companies never stop testing.

FAQs

What should I test first on my website?

Test your headline first. It’s the first thing visitors see and has the biggest impact on conversions. After that, test your call-to-action button text and placement, then your main images or videos.

Can A/B testing hurt my SEO?

No, if done correctly. Google supports A/B testing. Don’t cloak content, don’t use sneaky redirects, and make sure both versions serve the same content to search bots. SEO A/B testing is safe when you follow Google’s guidelines.

How much traffic do I need for A/B testing?

You need at least 1,000 visitors per variation (2,000 total) to get reliable results. If you have less traffic, focus on bigger changes that show clearer differences, or run tests longer.

What’s the difference between A/B testing and split testing?

They’re the same thing. A/B testing and split testing both mean comparing two versions of something. Some people use “split testing” to mean testing more than two versions (A/B/C/D testing), but usually the terms are interchangeable.

How much does A/B testing cost?

Free if you use Google Optimize or Microsoft Clarity. Professional tools like VWO cost £199-£500 per month. Hiring an agency costs £2,000-£10,000 per month. Most small businesses start free, then upgrade as they see results.

What’s a good conversion rate improvement from A/B testing?

Any improvement is good. Realistic improvements are 10-30% increase in conversions per test. Big wins (50-100% improvement) are rare but possible. The goal is consistent small wins that compound over time.

Should I test on mobile or desktop first?

Always test on mobile first. Over 60% of web traffic is mobile. If your test works on mobile, it’ll work on desktop. The reverse isn’t always true. Many tests fail because they only considered desktop users.

How do I know if my A/B test results are statistically significant?

Most A/B testing tools show you statistical significance automatically. Look for 95% confidence level or higher. This means there’s only a 5% chance your results happened by luck. Don’t trust results below 95% confidence.

A/B testing is the difference between guessing and knowing.

Stop wondering what works. Start testing and find out.

Your competitors are already doing this.

Don’t get left behind. Book a free call now:  Shieldonsystems to discuss your project!